DTaP vaccine, which includes the pertussis vaccine, is shown at Childhood Health Associates of Salem. Pertussis is sometimes referred to as whooping cough. / KOBBI R. BLAIR / Statesman Journal
By Liz Szabo, USA TODAY
For the first time, American researchers have found evidence
that the bacteria that cause whooping cough are becoming resistant to
vaccines, a new study shows.
Vaccine-resistant whooping cough has previously been documented in Japan, France and Finland, according to the report, published Thursday in The New England Journal of Medicine.
Public health officials have been particularly concerned about whooping cough, also known
as pertussis, because of recent outbreaks. Last year, the USA suffered
the largest whooping cough outbreak since 1955, with nearly 42,000
reported cases and 18 fatalities, according to the Centers for Disease
Control and Prevention. Most deaths were in children, particularly
babies under 3 months old. Newborns like these are too young to be fully
vaccinated, and their tiny airways can quickly swell shut.
Those cases are a fraction of the damage caused by whooping cough in
the pre-vaccine era. In the 1930s, doctors reported more than 250,000
cases a year, according to the CDC.
In the new study, genetic
tests showed signs of resistance in 11 of 12 children hospitalized for
whooping cough in Philadelphia in 2011 and 2012. The bacteria infecting
11 of these children lacked a key protein included in the pertussis
vaccine, which helps stimulate immunity to the disease.
While most of the hospitalized children were newborns, one was 9 and another 14.
The prospect of vaccine-resistant whooping cough is real concern, says
Michael Osterholm, director of the University of Minnesota's Center for
Infectious Disease Research and Policy.
Tuberculosis, which was
considered to be defeated by antibiotics, also has emerged as a serious
problem, as the number of cases of antibiotic-resistant tuberculosis has
grown, says William Schaffner, a professor at the Vanderbilt University
School of Medicine.
Those cases "may foretell a growing
problem," Schaffner says. While there has been little research on
resistant whooping cough in the USA, "This report will open up the
issue," Schaffner says.
Public health leaders still urge people
to get vaccinated against whooping cough, in spite of any limitations in
the vaccine. In addition to vaccinating children, the CDC now
recommends whooping cough shots for new parents and anyone else who
comes in contact with infants.
Recent studies suggest that
resistant forms of whooping cough can spread from person to person,
according to the Minnesota research center. Another study, published
Jan. 31 in Emerging Infectious Diseases, found that this new form of whooping cough is equally dangerous as the more common variety.
American scientists have been closely examining reasons for the
resurgence in whooping cough. Some outbreaks arise because of children
who are unvaccinated, or undervaccinated.
Scientists also have
found that the protection offered by the whooping cough vaccine fades
more quickly than previously thought.
So even fully vaccinated
children - who have received all five doses recommended by age 4 to 6 -
could still be vulnerable to the disease by age 10, according to a
September study in The New England Journal of Medicine.
Part of the difficulty in producing a better whooping cough vaccine
stems from the fact that researchers know relatively little about the
bacteria itself, at least compared with germs such as measles, Schaffner
says. Doctors don't know why, for example, even people "naturally"
infected with whooping cough may become reinfected a decade or so later.
In comparison, people who catch measles or chickenpox don't typically
get those infections again.